Tonicization

harmony 2 #jazz-theory#harmony

Tonicization is the trick of making a chord that isn’t “home” feel like home for a beat or two, then quietly walking back. You do it by attaching a dominant chord — a secondary dominant — to some other member of the key, borrowing the pull of V→I and pointing it somewhere else. The chord doesn’t actually change jobs in the functional sense; it just gets dressed up with a moment of arrival before the tune moves on.

What Actually Happens Harmonically

Every diatonic chord in a key can be treated, briefly, as if it were a tonic of its own. To do that, you precede it with the dominant seventh a fifth above it — this is the dominant seventh doing exactly what it always does, resolving down a fifth, except the target isn’t the “real” I. In C major, tonicizing the ii chord (Dm7) means borrowing A7 as its temporary V7:

  • Dm7 – A7 – Dm7 – G7 – Cmaj7
  • ii – V7/ii – ii – V – I

That A7 is labeled V7/ii (“five of two”) in Roman numeral analysis. It has no home elsewhere in the key of C — it exists only to point at Dm7 — and that’s the whole magic trick. The leading tone inside A7 (the note C♯) is the note that actually does the pulling, dragging the ear up to D.

Tonicization Is Not Modulation

This is the distinction that trips people up most. A modulation re-establishes a whole new key center with its own cadence and stays there (or takes real time getting back); tonicization is a one-to-four-bar visit that never leaves the home key in any structural sense. Dm7 in the example above is still just ii of C — it was ii before the A7 showed up and it’s ii after. Nothing about its diatonic function changed; it just got a spotlight.

You can also strengthen a tonicization by adding the related ii chord in front of the secondary dominant, turning V7/x into a full ii-V/x:

  • F♯m7♭5 – B7 – Em7 (in C major)
  • ii/iii – V7/iii – iii

Here F♯m7♭5–B7 is a miniature ii-V aimed at Em7 (iii), even though Em7 immediately hands the reins back to the diatonic progression around it.

Chains of Tonicization

Stack several secondary dominants back to back and you get a circle-of-fifths run through the whole key, tonicizing chord after chord. The bridge of a typical rhythm changes tune in B♭ does exactly this:

  • D7 – G7 – C7 – F7 – B♭maj7
  • V7/vi – V7/ii – V7/V – V7 – I

Only that last F7 is the “real” dominant of B♭; the D7, G7, and C7 are each secondary dominants tonicizing the chord a fifth below them, one after another around the circle of fifths. This same chain logic shows up wherever a bridge needs harmonic motion without a full key change, and it’s a favorite device when analyzing a standard. “All the Things You Are” leans on tonicization constantly — its first eight bars end with Dm7 – G7 – Cmaj7, a full ii-V briefly making C major feel like home inside a tune whose real tonic is A♭.

Substitutes for the Secondary Dominant

Jazz players rarely leave a secondary dominant plain. A passing diminished chord can stand in for it (vii°7/x instead of V7/x, e.g., C♯°7 in place of A7 before Dm7), giving the same resolution with a different color and voice-leading by half-step rather than by fifth. Either way, the underlying job is identical: create tension, then let dominant resolution deliver you to the tonicized chord.

♫ Listen

  • Coleman Hawkins — “Body and Soul” (1939): in the very first two bars (E♭m7 – B♭7 – E♭m7 in D♭), the B♭7 is V7/ii pulling right back to the ii chord — a tonicization you hear before the tune is four seconds old.
  • Miles Davis — “Oleo” (Bags’ Groove, 1954): the bridge of this rhythm changes tune is a bare chain of secondary dominants (D7 – G7 – C7 – F7 in B♭) — listen for how the soloists outline each new dominant as if it were briefly home.

Related: Secondary Dominants, Modulation, Turnarounds, Extended Dominants and Backcycling, Cadences in Jazz